Different Tranes
When an artist departs this realm at a relatively early age, acolytes frequently seek a sense of how that curtailed creativity would have evolved. Miles Davis was expected to continually enhance his interest in funk, groove, electronics, and hip-hop, surely set to run alongside each of his favored developments in new music. John Coltrane is another of 2026’s centenarians, and a similar fantasy retro-anticipation is far more difficult. There was no sign of Trane hitting the fusion racks in any kind of possible future. Close to the edge, he was delving radically into free jazz, with enlarged solos or duo cut-backs (Ascension and Interstellar Space, the latter being an intimate meeting with drummer Rashied Ali). We can’t imagine Coltrane heading into rock or funk. His more likely direction would have been to seep in quietness and meditation, working more closely with Alice Coltrane, reflecting the softer stretches of Pharoah Sanders and his more global-ethnic works. Surely?
Here, we will consider descendant players who have clearly been shaped (often in a revelatory fashion) by Trane’s existence, but those who have also taken his core essence, to formulate approaches that, in their own way, continue his legacy via a non-mimicking path.
The New York tenorman Michael Brecker can easily be seen as a key channeler, with his fingering virtuosity, exhaustive stamina and his seeking of ever-higher planes of expression via duration. Brecker’s early work with Dreams, Steps Ahead, and the Brecker Brothers is not particularly where we’re looking, but rather his later concentration on acoustic settings, as his trajectory refined itself. One LP that explicitly deals with the John Coltrane legacy is Directions In Music: Live At Massey Hall (Verve, 2002), with Roy Hargrove, Herbie Hancock, John Patitucci, and Brian Blade. Much of the material stems from the Miles Davis repertoire, but there is a significant Trane-wedge included. “Impressions” is taken at a softly slow lounge pace, but it’s to complement “So What,” with which the reading is intertwined. “Naima” has just Brecker alone, for a long introductory embracing of the theme, gradually revealed, his tenor solitary for the entire seven minute performance. This is one of the best examples of Brecker’s continuance in the Coltrane vein. Then, “Transition” brings in the entire combo, delivering a straighter rush of hyperactive energy, Brecker mobilized entirely, Herbie in full flow afterward. The closing “D Trane” (penned by Brecker) opens with a tirelessly inventive tenor solo, surging through half of the fifteen minute performance, leaving Hargrove little choice but to pepper sensitively with his own following solo, although it doesn’t take the trumpeter long to rise up to a more crackling, volatile state, Hancock ultimately crowning the climax of this solo-led number. The audience went wild, repeatedly, even as they laid low in the mix. This number acts as a shining distillation of Trane’s aura. (Brecker can also be heard on the more recently released Naima (Live) album via Delta Music, once again investigatively interpreting its key tune in an a capella state.)
One rogue, teetering presence by Brecker (plus trumpeter and brother Randy) is on Zappa In New York (Discreet, recorded in 1976), the 1978 double live LP where the pair employ parpling electronics in a very imaginative manner that hasn’t dated, aligned with the limb-twisting complexities of “The Purple Lagoon,” an epic side-four instrumental. We can just about visualize Trane being captured by the twistings of this Zappa direction, but he probably wouldn’t have played on the opening “Titties & Beer.”
More recently, the Washington Heights alto saxophonist Lakecia Benjamin has dedicated an LP to the music of the Coltranes (both Alice and John, fairly equally), a recording which has been partly instrumental in massively expanding her audience. The 2020 Pursuance: The Coltranes (Ropeadope) featured several guest artists (as is the today way), adding but not distracting from the mission. The Coltrane readings breathed in infusions of their joint creative powers, grasping the aura and attitudes. There’s a notable funking-up of “Syeeda’s Song Flute,” with Keyon Harrold guesting.
Although known as a funkster (with her early albums and Soul Squad band), Benjamin was a regular member of Rashied Ali’s quintet around two decades back, connecting her directly to the Coltrane flow, gigging excitingly around NYC clubs such as the Jazz Standard. Through Ali, she began playing with the recently departed guitarist James Blood Ulmer (who lived just across the street from the sticksman), touring with him toward the end of his active playing life. Now, Benjamin is still including a funk section as the climax of her live sets, but her recent albums have been addressing a harder, faster, more extreme bunch of tunes, and an ever-escalating soloing prowess, pushing further and higher than many saxophonists dare. ...